For non-religious purposes, would you recommend reading the Bible to an atheist, or are there more interesting books to read?

Yes No see voting resultssaving...
3 opinions, 2 replies
Add your opinion:
Preview:
(mouse over or touch to update)
Add your opinion
100
2 votes
Dec 6, 2015

Would I recommend that anyone read the Bible? Certainly. It has had a great deal of influence on Western language, art, culture, thought, politics and religion.

How it is read is most important. One has to understand its origins in ancient tribal religions, the times and cultures in which it was written, the fact that many books fall in the category of pseudepigrapha, someone or several people writing in the name of another person, or are compilations that were later ascribed to one author, and that it is a mixed bag of religious writing espousing several versions of God and different views of his relationship with humans.

As a former Christian Evangelical, I have been a student of the origins and of the New Testament and Old Testament for years. It was studying these origins and early church history that caused me to leave Evangelicalism. Presently, I am surprised that people can lend such credence to the content of a compilations such as the Bible without knowing its history and origins. I am ashamed to day that at one time I accepted it as the infallible and complete Word of God.

But read it? Certainly, though I suspect you might want to skip the genealogies and some other mundane areas. A cover-to-cover read is not necessary to detect the basis of its influence on Western culture and history.

subscribe
100
User voted Yes.
1 vote
Jul 13, 2016

What "non-religious purpose" would you want?

I'd say most atheists aren't going to scream at the mere notion of the Bible. But it's all about context. Are you just going to read Genesis? Are you going to RiffTrax the Bible, making fun of it? Or are you going to just read the cool part of Revelations?

Merely reading the Bible to anyone in the West is unlikely to do very much. Biblical imagery is deeply ensconced in our society: While there's a lot of inaccurate information and myths out there about the Bible, even those are based on cultural interaction with and remixing of the text. Even from an excitement perspective, you actually need to go kind of deep to get people interested. The Nephilim, Shedim, etc. are pretty cool and relatively unknown, so that'd be fun.

I wrote an opinion assuming you might want to excite someone on a religious basis. I'll leave it in for completion:

Because of the iconic nature of Biblical imagery, if you find the Bible compelling, that's fine, but don't expect many people outside of your faith tradition who have relatively certain beliefs to be swayed.

I have a friend who, in elementary and middle school, suddenly became an evangelical Christian because he had a dream about the four Horsemen. He insisted he hadn't read those passages in the Bible, but even at the time I pointed out that the Four Horsemen are such a cultural fixture that the idea that he hadn't heard of them even once was just ludicrous. The principle of parsimony made clear that it was far more likely that he had absorbed the idea through cultural osmosis than anything else.

Today, he's a relatively left-leaning fireman in the Pacific Northwest whose spirituality is very clearly non-denominational and skeptical.

Even if you have a big (literal) "Come to Jesus" moment just from reading the Bible, it may be short-lived.

Worse, the Bible is actually really boring, and there are glaring contradictions in it. I know, many Christians (and Jews and Muslims) believe there are interpretations that can rectify the apparent contradictions. It's noteworthy that there are in fact many such interpretations: dispensationalism, for example, is just one form of supersessionism, and while most Christian groups are supersessionist to some degree, not all are.

If you really want to try to engage with people from different faith backgrounds, try this:

  • Pick a few passages that really speak to you. Try to communicate what you think it says in a way that shows what moves you about it.
  • Listen to some of their criticisms of parts of the text. Find some context and come back to them with a broader context or interpretation. At the very worst, you'll deepen your own faith and understanding!
  • Suggest books that might help them see the text better. Try to avoid really obviously propagandistic texts like Heaven Is For Real or the Left Behind series: there are some good texts with a Christian ethos, like Chronicles of Narnia or The Lord of the Rings. Those latter two are too well-known, but you can probably find less well-known ones that might be a good opening.
If you're going to do this, of course, recognize that if you're going to ask others to engage with you, you should engage with them. If you really feel someone will benefit from reading Left Behind, you should be prepared to read God Is Not Great.
subscribe
0
User voted Yes.
0 votes
Feb 24, 2016

Yes I would it's would it's how I became and atheist. Really religion isn't a place to get your morality from. Most religions are full of KILL, ENSLAVE, etc., yes that not only includes the bible but the quran the torah also

subscribe
::unhide-discussion::
0
main reply
0 votes,
Jul 13, 2016

Salvation in the Bible. But i can't advice religion to other man, each of us given the opportunity to choose our future and faith!

subscribe
::unhide-discussion::
100
User voted Yes.
1 vote,
Jul 17, 2016

Salvation in the Bible? Really, so it's ok to sell daughters into slavery? Exodus 21:7-11 How about what J-E-S-U-S said about slaves Ephesians 6:5 "Slaves, obey your earthly masters with deep respect and fear. Serve them sincerely as you would serve Christ. " so Jesus was OK with people owning slaves. Or maybe Luke 12:47-48, I'm not going to post all the verses here since you said salvation in the bible, I'm going to assume you have read it or at least can look up the verses.

Or maybe we should kill people who don't listen to the priest Deuteronomy 17:12 or gays Leviticus 20:13 or killing an entire town if they don't follow your god Deuteronomy 13:13-19 and those who follow a different religion Deuteronomy 13:7-12

Religion isn't a place to get your morals.

subscribe
Add your opinion
Challenge someone to answer this topic:
Invite an OpiWiki user:
OR
Invite your friend via email:
OR
Share it: