100
opinion
2 votes
May 7, 2015

Not even through the state, but the county. There are many counties within a state and only they can truly know how to help the poor in their community. They can see it everyday. The state however does not.

Reply to this opinion
subscribe
::unhide-discussion::
0
linked reply
0 votes,
May 7, 2015

The help itself may come at the county level but the money has to come from a much higher level. In states that fund their schools at the county level the poorest counties normally have the biggest problem funding their school. They are a poor county because they have so many poor in that county.

If private help worked then why are the poor not receiving the help they need? It sounds good but many of the people saying are just looking for a line their supporters will buy that will lower the tax rate but very little of those tax savings will be given to the private charities.

subscribe
::unhide-discussion::
0
0 votes,
Jul 10, 2015

The idea that poverty can only be fixed with money (and education) is a serious (and almost insulting) misconception. People need a sense of direction and the feeling that they can rely on something (/security) when their future is uncertain. Wealthy people aren't (usually) wealthy by accident; they made it happen.

It's a difference in attitude of mind (although of course I should add that I'm currently generalizing, as I haven't ever visited these counties, have little to no knowledge of US tax rates or the conditions these people are living in).

"Poor people" (people with incomes that don't sustain their basic human needs) need help, but mostly they need to feel taken care of (in an un-patronizing manner) and feel accepted within the community. To propose a concrete idea (shoot it down if you will <- or perhaps this already happened): the state should finance the county to literally clean up the streets, restore buildings that are valuable to the community, issue orders for agricultural maintenance (perhaps with the aid of low-level crime offenders), and just make the county a pleasant place to live in that's worth working for.

subscribe
Challenge someone to answer your opinion:
Invite an OpiWiki user:
OR
Invite your friend via email:
OR
Share it: